Supreme Court of Oklahoma February 9, 1926, 14575 (Concordia Fire Insurance Co. v. Wise)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-02-1926
•CLARK, J.
This is an appeal from the judgment rendered in the district court of Craig county, Okla., in favor of defendants in error and against the several plaintiffs in error in an action to recover for the loss by fire on January 3, 1922, of a building and the contents thereof, at Vinita, Okla.
The plaintiffs in error are the insurance companies which carried insurance on the said property. Separate actions were filed against each company on the policy or policies issued by it. The Concordia Fire Insurance Company was sued for $6,000; the Retailers Fire Insurance Company was sued for $21,000; the Patriotic Assurance Company was sued for $4,000; and the Patriotic Assurance Company was sued by1 the receiver for $2,000; the total amount of the insurance carried on the property being $33,-000. The several cases were consolidated by agreement and -stipulation between plaintiffs and defendants in the trial court and the action went to trial before a jury in the case against the defendant Concor-dia Fire Insurance Company; W., L. Lyons being the owner, and insured, of the furniture store and rooming house, and a mem-iter of an undertaking, furniture and mercantile company known as Taylor & Lyons, of which company P. H. Crahan was receiver and as such joined as party plaintiff with Lyons in the suit in the trial court.
The defendants filed their answer and raised the sole question of¡ the origin of the fire, and alleged that the plaintiff willfully, intentionally, and deliberately set fire to and destroyed the property mentioned in said petitions and policies.
The plaintiffs replied by a general denial in each ease. Upon the issues thus joined a trial was had.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit