Court of Appeals of Texas March 18, 1926, No. 1862. (Hudspeth v. Hilburn)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-03-1926
HIGGINS, J.
Appellees, Hilburn and Me-Orea, brought this suit against the appellant to recover upon two notes of the latter in the sum of $11,500 each, less an admitted credit of $4,766.
The appellants pleaded the payment and acceptance of said amount of $4,766 in accord and satisfaction of the notes sued upon. The evidence does not disclose any controversy between the parties as to the amount due thereon, but does disclose that the appellant was heavily involved financially. The question presented is whether the payment of the sum mentioned operated a,s a satisfaction of the debt for the greater amount evidenced by the notes sued upon.
The trial court found that defendant agreed to pay and plaintiffs agreed to accept $5,000 in payment of the notes; that defendant paid the sum of $4,766, but failed to pay the balance of $234. Appellant challenges the correctness of this finding, but an examination of the evidence discloses that it supports the same. According to the testimony of appellant, the payment of $4,766 was made and accepted in full satisfaction. McCrea represented the plaintiffs in the negotiation. While McOrea’s testimony upon the issue is somewhat confusing, yet, viewing the same most favorably to appellant, it appears that appellant informed him he was endeavoring to effect a settlement with all of his creditors; that if the other creditors accepted his of
*315
fer he could only pay appellees $4,766, but, if they did not, he could and would pay $5,-000. There is no claim that the other creditors accepted, so, according to McCrea’s testimony, the obligation was to pay them $5,-000. That the agreement was to pay $5,000 is strongly evidenced by a letter of appellant, accompanying the check for $4,766, in which he said:
“Enclosed ek for $4,766 — as promised. I could not
get
down to Stamford and sorry to disappoint you but this leaves me absolutely flat and I certainly appreciate you and will * * * make the other up to $5,000 as soon as I possibly can.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit