California Court of Appeal January 27, 1927, Docket No. 5464. (Kruse v. White Brothers)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-01-1927

CASHIN, J.

Appeals by defendants from a judgment entered on a verdict for the plaintiffs in an action to recover for personal injuries.

*89

E. A. Kruse is the husband of Madeline C. Kruse, and the latter—who will be hereinafter referred to as the plaintiff—while crossing a public highway known as the Alameda, near its intersection with Tosemite Avenue in Berkeley, Alameda County, was injured by an automobile owned by the corporation defendant and operated by Meyer, one of its employees. As grounds for reversal of the judgment it is urged by appellant corporation that the evidence is insufficient to sustain a finding that Meyer was acting within the scope of his employment, and that certain instructions to the jury were prejudicially erroneous; and, by appellant Meyer, that the only inferences reasonably to be drawn from the evidence support his special defense of contributory negligence.

Meyer, who resided in Oakland, was there employed as a salesman for the corporation, a dealer in hardwood lumber, with its place of business in San Francisco. According to the testimony his working hours commenced at 8 A. M. and ended at 5 P. M., it being his duty during those hours to solicit orders for his employer, for which purpose the automobile was furnished by the latter. The automobile when not in use was kept in a garage in the possession of Meyer, the employer making a money allowance for this service. Some days before the date of the accident—which occurred on November 23, 1921, at about 6 P. M.—Bruce Bartholomew, who wished to purchase a quantity of hardwood lumber, communicated his wants to Meyer, and the testimony tends to show that it was the intention of the latter on the evening of the accident to call at the Bartholomew residence, which was situated at Colusa Avenue between San Pedro and Tacoma Avenues, one block southwest of the Alameda. At about 5 P. M.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.