Supreme Court of North Carolina December 21, 1927 (Hearn v. . Ostrander)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-12-1927
ConNOr, J.
Tbe testimony of plaintiff, together with other evidence in bis behalf, pertinent to tbe first issue, was properly submitted to tbe jury, and although sharply contradicted by evidence in behalf of defendants, was sufficient to sustain tbe answer of tbe jury to said issue. No assignments of error on defendants’ appeal to this Court are based upon exceptions to evidence pertinent to this issue, or to instructions of tbe court more particularly applicable to said issue.
Plaintiff, however, is not entitled to recover in this action upon an affirmative answer to tbe first issue. It is conceded by bis counsel tbat the-words which tbe jury has found were spoken of and concerning plaintiff by defendant, C. B. Ostrander, on tbe occasion referred to in tbe complaint, were privileged. This defendant bad received information, as superintendent of the plant of tbe Ford Motor Company, tending to show tbat plaintiff, an employee of said company, bad on several occasions, in tbe city of Charlotte, swapped Champion spark plugs of tbe kind used by said company in its plant for equipping its cars, for gasoline, under circumstances which properly aroused tbe suspicion of bis informant tbat plaintiff’s possession of the said spark plugs was unlawful. It was manifestly tbe duty of said defendant, as superintendent of tbe plant, in which plaintiff was employed, to investigate this matter. Tbe words complained of by plaintiff were spoken by said defendant while conducting said investigation. Upon all tbe evidence, tbe occasion on which tbe words were spoken by defendant, Ostrander,
*755
was such tbat they constitute a privileged communication, for which no action lies unless the words were spoken with actual malice. Plaintiff, therefore, cannot recover in this action unless there was evidence tending to sustain an affirmative answer to the second issue, and unless, further, such evidence was submitted to the jury by the court under instructions which are free from error.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit