Texas Commission of Appeals November 23, 1927, No. 978-4826 (Greenlaw v. Dilworth)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-11-1927

NICKELS, ,J.

The case is generally stated' in the opinion of the Court of Civil Appeals. 291 S. W. 331. It was brought to the Supreme Court upon assignments challenging jurisdiction in the Court of Civil Appeals to render final judgment contrary to that of the trial court.

A Court of Civil Appeals “may draw from the evidence conclusions of fact different from those arrived at by the jury or judge, and it may reverse the judgment of the lower court and remand the. cause for the reason that it thinks the verdict and judgment to be against the weight of the evidence, but the determination of questions of fact as the basis of a final judgment involves the exercise of original jurisdiction which has not been conferred upon the Courts of Civil Appeals.” H. & T. C. Ry. Co. v. Strycharski, 92 Tex. 1, 37 S. W. 415; Choate v. S. A. Ry. Co., 91 Tex. 406, 44 S. W. 69; Sprinkles v. Kerbow (Tex. Com. App.) 279 S. W. 805, and eases there cited.

The evidence is not stated, even by way of summary, in the opinion of the Court of-Civil Appeals; it is there dealt with only in the manner of general ultimate conclusions. Nor did that court make finding upon preponder.ance or sufficiency of evidence, as was done in Sprinkles v. Kerbow, supra. Judgment awarding final relief was rendered by that court, and this involves a finding that the evidence tends in one direction with that conclusiveness which leaves no ground'for combat of rational minds. The situation thus projected gives rise to our duty to examine the entire record and therefrom to ascertain, with the aid of relevant formularies, whether there be that cogency of proof which is the postulate of the final award.

Because there is much in seeing a witness (H. & T. C. Ry. Co. v. Gray, 105 Tex. 42, 143 S. W.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.