Louisiana Court of Appeal May 9, 1927, No. 10,862 (Kelly v. During)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-05-1927

CLAIBORNE, J.

This is a suit by a tenant against his landlord for damages arising out of alleged defective premises.

The plaintiff alleged that he occupied the premises, 2138 Elysian Fields Avenue, as lessee of the defendant; that on November 12, 1926, the premises caught fire and his movable property therein was damaged and he was compelled to move; that the fire was caused by the defective electric wiring in said premises. He claimed $138.50 damages and $15.00 cost of moving.

The defendant admitted the fire but averred “that she is in no wise liable for any damages caused to said plaintiff for the reason that, under the law, she was required to have the electric wiring in said premises inspected by the Fire Prevention Bureau, and that said bureau inspected the wiring in said premises and approved the same as to safety, and that the same was also approved by the City Electrician, and that if any defect existed therein respondent is not liable, for the reason that she cannot be held liable for the laches or faults of the officials required to make said inspection".

There was judgment rejecting plaintiff’s demand and he has appealed.

The liability of the lessor to answer in damages for vices or defects in the leased premises is at this date too firmly established to admit of discussion.

Civil Code 2695 (2665) reads as follows:

“The lessor guarantees the lessee against all the vices and defects of the thing (leased) and if any loss should result to the lessee from the vices an,d defects, the lessor shall be bound to indemnify him for the same.”

Jurisprudence has confirmed this language:

Schoppel vs. Daly, 112 La. 213, 36 South. 322.

St. Landry Whsle. Merc. Co. vs. New Hampshire Fire Ins. Co., 114 La. 146, 38 South. 87.

Bianchi vs. Del Valle, 117 La. 592, 42 South. 148.

Lochbaun vs. Southwestern Box & Lbr. Mfg. Co., 121 La. 176, 46 South. 201.

Bennett vs. Southern Scrap Material Co., 121 La. 204, 46 South. 211.

Wise vs. Lavigne, 138 La. 139, 218, 70 South. 103.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.