Supreme Court of Kansas January 8, 1927, Nos. 25,425 and 27,007 (Van Deren v. Heineke & Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-01-1927

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Dawson, J.:

This was an action for damages for breach of a contract under which plaintiff held the agency for the sale of threshing-machine feeders manufactured by defendant.

Defendant is a foreign corporation not authorized to transact its corporate business in Kansas, and plaintiff resorted to two methods of service to bring defendant into court in Sedgwick county. One of these was to cause summons to defendant to be served on one J. Wirth Sargent, a member of a firm of lawyers in Wichita employed to look after defendant’s legal affairs. Mr. Sargent had busied himself about the matter of getting defendant’s machines, wares and other personalty shipped to St. Louis, and may have performed other services either directly for defendant or as a junior member of the law firm employed by defendant.

Another method of service was attempted through summons to defendant served upon the secretary of state in the manner authorized by the statute for service on foreign corporations which have received lawful authority to exercise their corporate activities in this state. (R. S. 17-504.)

The first method of service was sharply challenged in the trial court, and affidavits and other evidence were presented bearing upon the questioned agency of J. Wirth Sargent to accept or submit to service of summons on behalf of defendant. The trial court quashed the service on Sargent; and plaintiff’s appeal from that ruling is case No. 25,425.

Defendant’s motion to quash the service of summons through the secretary of state was overruled, and apparently defendant acquiesced in that ruling. It made a general appearance by filing a motion to strike out certain matter from plaintiff’s petition. (King v. Ingels, 121 Kan. 790, 250 Pac. 306.) This motion was sustained. Defendant then filed a demurrer to the petition, which was overruled; and defendant answered with a general denial.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.