Baltimore City Circuit Court December 14, 1927 (Weer v. Page)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-12-1927
STANTON, J.
(Orally)
Gentlemen, I have read the cases cited on the briefs and I find a great many of those cases are cases in which courts are dealing with a review on an appeal of the action of a banking commission or official, by reason of the fact that the law of the particular State provided for a review or appeal from *651either the banking commission or the banking commissioner, whichever was the proper official dealing with the banking affairs of that State. So in this State the Legislature has delegated certain administrative functions to various commissions and boards, and wherever and whenever it was intended to have their action reviewed by the courts on appeal, such an appeal was authorized and the machinery provided to effectuate it. This is illustrated in the appeals from the Workmen’s Compensation Commission, where also is authorized certiorari to review the records controlling action in specified matters, and in the appeals from the Public Service Commission, and the Board of Motion Picture Censors and the Automobile Commissioner. There is no appeal authorized in the State Banking Act to review the action of the State Bank Commissioner.
Plaintiffs contend, however, that although no appeal is provided in law, nevertheless, the action of the Bank Commissioner is subject to review under the general power in the court of equity to review and correct any unlawful action by an administrative official. A court of equity can and does review the action of the Public Service Commission because the statute expressly so provides. Even then the Court cannot substitute its judgment for the judgment of the Commission, but can only say whether the order passed is either unlawful or unreasonable, and it passes on the record made before the Commission in such a case, and never affords a new hearing or proceeding.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit