Supreme Court of the United States April 9, 1928, 344 (Work v. Braffet)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-04-1928

Mr. Justice Stone

delivered the opinion of the Court.

Respondent’s intestate brought suit in the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia for a mandatory injunction compelling the Secretary of the Interior to vacate his decision rejecting an application under R. S. § 2347 for the purchase of certain coal lands included in

*562

the school-land grant to Utah, and directing that a patent issue. The case was heard on bill and answer from which it appears that the land in question, is part of section 32 in a particular township in Utah. Section 32 of each township was included in the school-land grant to the state of Utah under the Enabling Act of July 16, 1894, c. 138, 28 Stat. 107, 109, which became effective on the admission of Utah into the Union January 4, 1896. But the grant did not include any land that was known to be mineral.

United States

v.

Sweet,

245 U. S. 563. In the official government survey the land in question was reported by the surveyor as non-mineral. In May, 1902, the state sold the lands and the purchaser later conveyed them to the Pleasant Valley Coal Company which has since appeared as the record owner and paid taxes on them. On February 4, 1918, Braffet, respondent’s intestate, filed in the local land office at Salt Lake City his application to purchase the lands as coal lands. At this time and for many years before, the settled practice of the Land Office, under Rule 1 of the Regulations of March 6, 1903, 32 L. D. 39, had been to treat applications for purchase, under the mining laws, of parts of a section designated in the school-land grant, where made after the date when the grant would attach if the land was non-mineral, as a contest of the state’s right.

Braffet’s application was so treated. The state was cited and answered, protesting the application and setting up that the lands were not known coal lands on the date of the grant to it. The coal company intervened and made like answer.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.