Supreme Court of the United States November 19, 1928, 48 (United States v. Lenson)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-11-1928

Mr. Justice Holmes

delivered the opinion of the Court.

This is a claim by a lieutenant qf the Staff Corps of the Navy, under the Act of June 10, 1922., c. 212, 42 Stat. 625, (Code, Title 37, §§ 1, 4,) which went into effect on July 1, 1922, that by § 1 of that Act he is "entitled to pay of the fourth period there mentioned from the date of the Act to April 23,1924, amounting to $1,935.89. On the last date he had served seventeen years, as enlisted man and officer, and since then has received fourth period pay. The Court of Claims gave the claimant judgment for the sum named. A writ of certiorari, was granted by this Court, 276 U. S. 612.

As stated by his counsel the claimant had been in continuous service for over fifteen years when the Act took effect, about eleven years as enlisted man, six months as a warrant officer and three and a half years as commissioned officer. His first appointment in the permanent service in the Navy was as a lieutenant, junior grade, of the Staff Corps, corresponding to a first lieutenant in the

*62

Army. The pay of the fourth period, $3,000, is given “to lieutenants of the Staff Corps of the Navy, and lieutenants and lieutenants (junior grade) of the line and Engineer Corps of the Coast Guard whose total commissioned seryiee equals that of lieutenant commanders of the line of the Navy drawing the pay of this period.” The absence of a comma after ‘Coast Guard’ is laid hold of to show that the qualification as to commissioned service applies only to the last clause and not to lieutenants of the Staff Corps of the Navy, but no intelligible reason is given for limiting it in that way. The length of commissioned service seems in reason as proper a consideration in determining the pay of orfe class as of the other. If then the' claimant’s total commissioned service must have equaled that of lieutenant commanders of the Navy drawing fourth period pay, we are of opinion that his claim must fail.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.