California Court of Appeal September 21, 1928, Docket No. 1679. (People v. Stern)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-09-1928
HOUSER, J.
Defendant appeals from a judgment of conviction of the crime of burning insured property and from an order denying his motion for a new trial.
The first point made by appellant for reversal of the judgment is that the verdict of the jury was not supported by the evidence. Among other facts, many of which at least were not antagonistic to a conclusion that defendant was wholly innocent-of wrongdoing, the following may be mentioned as bearing upon the question of the sufficiency of.the evidence to support the verdict, to wit: Defendant was the proprietor of a millinery store. Referring to the stock of goods in the store, each of two witnesses for the prosecution testified in effect that immediately after the fire, “practically all of it was saturated with gasoline”; and that although several articles of such stock of goods which gave off the odor of gasoline were produced as exhibits on the trial of the action, “not anywheres near all of it” was present in court. In addition thereto, a cardboard box which was inside a carton “containing scraps of material” was found in the storeroom, which box not only gave off the odor of gasoline, but which “contained a small quantity of gasoline that had not been saturated into the fibers of the box.” Defendant stated that he had no enemy against whom suspicion might be directed as to the person who had started the fire. There was but one set of keys
*87
to the store, which keys were carried by defendant. “The material that was burned was on the south side of the room around the sewing-machine table, and on top of the sewing-machine table, and under the table which set just west of the sewing machine. . . . There was fire under the table which set just west,”—which table was about six or eight feet from where the sewing-machine table was located. Although the business of defendant was “on the mend,” at the time the fire occurred, it was “none too good.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit