California Court of Appeal May 21, 1928, Docket No. 6069. (Humphreys v. City & County of San Francisco)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-05-1928

LUCAS, J.,

pro

tem.

By this action the ten parties plaintiff (appellants herein), residents and taxpayers of, and property owners in, the City and County of San Francisco, seek, on behalf of themselves and 1,700 other property owners, to enjoin the mayor and board of supervisors of said City and County from collecting assessments levied for the construction of a tunnel through Buena Vista Park, and through, over, and upon a portion of Duboce Park. Buena Vista Park lies on a high ridge of land separating that part of San Francisco lying easterly of the eastern portal of the proposed tunnel and generally known as the “down town section,” and a residential part of said city lying west of the western portal of said tunnel and known as the “Sunset district.” The purpose of the tunnel is to provide a way of rapid transit between these two sections of the city.

Proceedings were taken hy the board of supervisors under the provisions of the so-called “Tunnel Procedure Ordinance,” resulting in the assessments complained of. Authority for the enactment of this ordinance is found in certain charter amendments adopted by the electors of the City and County of San Francisco in December, 1912, and ratified by the state legislature in 1913. (Stats. 1913', at p. 1621.) These amendments contain the following provisions relating to the construction of tunnels:

“Section 1. The Board of Supervisors are hereby empowered to order the construction of and construct any tunnel, subway or viaduct in, on, under or over any accepted

*72

or unaccepted open public street, avenue, lane, alley, place or court within the City and County, or any other land of the City and County. . . .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.