Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) May 4, 1928 (Board of Trustees v. City of Paducah)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-05-1928
Opinion of the Court by
Judge Rees
Affirming.
• The board of trustees of the Carnegie Public Library brought this action against the city of Paducah to recover $50,000. The defendant’s demurrer to the petition was sustained by the lower court and the petition dismissed. The library was established in T902 partly with a donation made by Andrew Carnegie, and, in the contract between Carnegie and the city, the latter agreed to pay to the library $3,500 annually to maintain and support it.
Section 3210, Kentucky Statutes, provides, that, in aid of the establishment and maintenance of a public library in cities of the second class, to which Paducah belongs, there shall be paid to the library ‘ ‘ one-half* of the net amount of all fines and costs collected in the police court.” One-half of the net amount of all fines and costs actually paid into the city treasury has been paid to the library, and it is conceded that the portion of the fines and costs paid to it amounts to $10,000 annually.
The petition alleges that, under the provision of the statute above quoted, the library is also entitled to one-half of all fines and costs worked out on the streets or public works of the city, and that the amount due the library under this claim is $25,000. The disposition of this question depends on the definition of the word “collected” as used in the statute referred to. It is the contention of the appellant that fines and costs collected in the police court mean all fines and costs, whether paid in cash or worked out on the streets or public works of the city. "With this contention we cannot agree. The word “collected,” as used in the statute, means recovered into the city treasury in money.
A somewhat similar statute was construed by this court in Power v. Fleming County, 99 Ky. 200, 35 S. W. 541, 18 Ky. Law Rep. 61. There the county attorney of Fleming county sought to recover 3 per centum of fines imposed in inferior courts and not paid in cash but worked out by the defendants.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit