Michigan Supreme Court January 3, 1928, Docket No. 144. (Dolomite Limestone Products Co. v. Kennedyman Saun Manfg. & Engineering Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-01-1928

Sharpe, J.

The plaintiff is engaged in the manufacture of pulverized limestone for agricultural purposes and as an asphalt filler. The defendant manufactures mills or machines for that purpose. On April 24, 1924, a contract in writing was entered into for the purchase by plaintiff of one of defendant’s mills described as a

“4' x

8' Airswept Tube Mill,” at the price of $6,268. It was delivered on or about June 1st, and the first payment made thereon. On June 29, 1925, there was default in payment, and defendant brought replevin and recovered possession. On July 1, 1925, plaintiff brought this action for damages claimed to have been suffered by it by reason of false representations alleged to have been made to it which induced the purchase. It had verdict for $9,051.50. On defendant’s motion for a new trial, the court required plaintiff to remit the sum of $2,500, and, on this being done, a judgment was entered in its favor for the balance of $6,551.50. Defendant seeks review by writ of error.

Counsel are agreed that the measure of plaintiff’s damages, if any, was the difference between the value, of the mill had it been as represented and its value when delivered to plaintiff. The trial court so instructed the jury.

The representations on which plaintiff claims it relied are thus stated by its counsel:

“The representations made were that the mill manufactured by the defendant was suitable to plaintiff’s

*281

business; that it was designed and equipped to manufacture at a single operation asphalt filler and. agricultural limestone; that defendant’s mill was capable of producing four tons or more per hour of the filler of the required fineness, when not engaged in providing chips, and was capable of producing 3 and 8/10 tons per hour of the filler of the required fineness.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.