Superior Court of Pennsylvania April 10, 1928, Appeal 1533 (Wally Et Ux. v. Baldwin)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-04-1928

Opinion by

Cunningham, J.,

The action below was trespass for injuries to real estate. A non-suit was entered as to two of the plaintiffs, Frank and Magdalena Wally, and a verdict rendered in favor of their co-plaintiffs, Anthony and Hose Wally. The verdict in their favor, supported as it is by evidence, established the fact of injury. The only substantial question involved under the assignments of error filed by the defendant in support of his appeal from the judgment entered upon the verdict, after his motions for a new trial and for judgment n. o. v. had been denied, is whether the court below in admitting certain offers of evidence and in its charge to the jury adopted a correct measure of damages: From the evidence these material facts appeared: in 1916 plaintiffs purchased a lot at the southwest corner of State and 24th Streets in the City of Erie, fronting 40 feet on State Street and extending westwardly along the south side of 24th Street 165 feet, with a width in the rear of 51.85 feet. Across the rear end of this lot they built a bungalow in 1917 at a cost of about $7,000, the western 'side of the building, approximately 50 feet in length, being eight feet from the rear line of the lot.

In 1922 George D. Baldwin, the defendant, became

*201

the owner of a lot on the east side of Peach Street (a north and south street parallel with State Street and 330 feet west thereof), located 30 feet south of 24th Street, with a frontage of 69.7 feet, and extending eastwardly, of equal "width, 165 "feet, the resulting situation being that these lots abut upon each other for a distance of 21.85 feet in the .rear of each lot. Peach Street is laid out along the top of a bluff and its elevation is 41 feet above that of State Street. Passing from the front of defendant’s lot eastwardly toward State Street, the surface is approximately level for about two-thirds of its length and then comes a' steep descent, at a grade of about 50 per cent.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.