Superior Court of Pennsylvania April 10, 1928, Appeal 36 (Savic Ex Rel. Bobic v. Pittsburgh Gas Coal Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-04-1928

Opinion by

Henderson, J.,

The claimant is the widow of Marko Bobic. They were married in Austria-Hungary in 1897. The husband came twice to the United States, the last time in 1913. His object was to secure better employment than was obtainable in his native country, Austria-Hungary. On June 27, 1920, while working for the defendant in a coal mine in Indiana County in this State, he received injuries in an accident, as a result of which he died on November 3, 1920. He came to this country with the consent of his wife who did not accompany him. Her compensation claim was disallowed by the referee on the conclusion that she was not dependent. On appeal to the Compensation Board, additional testimony was taken and a rehearing had, after which an award was made by the Board in favor of the claimant. An appeal to the Court of Common Pleas followed where the finding of the Board was reversed; the court being of the opinion that the petitioner had failed to establish a situation of dependency. The only question for consideration therefore is whether the record exhibits any evidence or admits any -reasonable inferences from that taken that she was actually dependent on her husband for support. If there be any evidence on which the conclusion of the Board may rest, that is the end of the controversy, as the only subject brought up on appeal is one of law. It is not important therefore that in the judgment of the appellate tribunal the weight of the evidence is against the claim, for that court is in no sense the trier of the facts involved, nor authorized to disregard the evidence of unimpeached witnesses which

*497

is not of such a contradictory and improbable character as to require its exclusion from consideration by the Board having exclusive jurisdiction to weigh the whole evidence and the inferences which may be fairly dedueible therefrom. Nor is it necessary that the claimant make it appear that she was wholly dependent on her husband for support.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.