Court of Appeals of Texas November 7, 1928, No. 7278. (Fuller Construction Co. v. Hudson)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-11-1928

BLAIR, J.

By deed appellee conveyed the property involved in this suit to C. W. Bur-ney, retaining a vendor’s lien to secure a $3,-

*542

700 purchase-money note, which was also secured by a deed of trust containing the usual power of sale clause. After Burney purchased the property, he used it as a homestead. Thereafter he and his wife executed to appellant a mechanic’s lien on their said homestead to secure the payment of his share of the costs of paving the street in front of and abutting thereon. Still later, and in default of payment of the $3,700 purchase-money note by Burney, appellee- caused the property to be sold -under the power granted in the deed of trust, and purchased the property at the trustee’s sale. He then brought this suit to remove the cloud from title created by the filing and recording of appellant’s aforementioned mechanic’s lien, and recovered judgment removing the cloud. By this appeal appellant attacks that judgment upon the following grounds:

1. That a holder of a vendor’s lien note cannot claim the homestead character of the property in a suit like this, but the owner only may claim that exemption. The contention is not sustained. In the case of State Trust Co. v. Morrison (Tex. Com. App.) 282 S. W. 214, which is identical in point of fact with this case, it is held (a) that a vendor’s lien on a homestead is superior to a mechanic’s lien executed to secure the payment of owner’s share of costs of paving abutting street; (b) that such mechanic’s lien is not created under section 37 of article 16 of the Constitution, providing for mechanic’s, ma-terialmen’s, etc., liens, but by contract under section 50 of said article, providing for liens by contract on homesteads; and (c) that the statutory lien created by article 5459, R. S.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.