Texas Commission of Appeals January 4, 1928, No. 1045-4967 (Hubb Diggs Co. v. Bell)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-01-1928
NICKELS, J.
The case is fully stated in the opinion of the Court of Civil Appeals. 297 S. W. 682. See also (Tex. Com. App.) 293 S. W. 808.
Por instant purposes, it .is sufficient to say: (a) Dangerous and reckless speed made up or was included in negligence charged respectively against the company and the deceased. (b) That negligence as proximate cause of the collision and Bell’s death was charged against the company and the deceased, (c) The jury found the speed of the company’s truck and of Bell’s motorcycle to have been, respectively, 26 and 38 miles per hour, (d) The company’s act was negligent, but that of Bell was not negligent, according to the verdict, (e) The collision happened at a street intersection in Port Worth, (f) Bell’s approach to the intersection was marked by negligence in omission to give signals, but this was not a proximate cause — according to the verdict, (g) Bell was a policeman, and at the time of the collision he was answering an emergency call, (h) Lewis was Bell’s superior and in charge of that department of the police organization of the city to which Bell belonged. (i) Amongst the facts shown by plaintiff (Mrs. Bell) upon which the finding against negligence in Bell’s conduct rests is a “custom for motorcycle officers in Port Worth * * * while employed by the city on emergency calls to travel at high speed in answering those calls” and existence of “an order from the captain” (Lewis) “about the rate of speed” those officers should make. (j) Amongst the facts subsequently sought to be developed by the company is the fact that by the “rules and regulations” issued “by the
chief of the motorcycle squad” (i. e., by Lewis) it is provided that such officers “should not operate their motorcycles at a greater rate of speed than 35 miles an hour, under any circumstances.” . (k) Upon objection that the regulation was not embodied in an ordinance, evidence by which it was offered to be shown was excluded.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit