Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York March 15, 1928 (Stokes v. Ottoman American Development Co.)

Peb Cubiam.

We are of the opinion that none of the counterclaims states a cause of action against the defendant William E. D. Stokes, Jr. The subject-matter of the first counterclaim is the obtaining by the plaintiff, by means of false representations, of certain notes and stock which it is alleged the plaintiff refuses *740to return.