Supreme Court of the United States June 3, 1929, 674 (Kirk v. Maumee Valley Electric Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-06-1929
Mr. Justice Stone
delivered the opinion of the Court.
This is a direct appeal under § 266 of the Judicial Code from a final, decree, following an interlocutory decree, of a district court of three judges for southern Ohio. The decree enjoined appellants, the Superintendent of Public Works of Ohio, a state officer, the City of Toledo, certain villages in Ohio, and the Board of County Commissioners of Lucas County, Ohio, from draining or otherwise interfering with the flow of water in a section of the Miami & Erie Canal in such manner as to interfere with rights of appellee to take surplus water from the canal under certain leases and a grant acquired by it or its assignors from the state. Appellee contends that the Act of the Ohio legislature of May 11, 1927, under which appellants purport to act, is in violation of the Federal Constitution.
The section of the canal in question extends from a point on the Maumee River northeasterly along the river
*799
to Toledo and thence to Lake Erie. The water from the river enters this section of the-canal at its western end and flows past the Providence Mills involved in No. 675,
Kirk.
v.
Providence Mill Co., post,
p. 807. Some sixteen miles from the inlet is a side-cut through which water may be discharged into the river and so ctiverted from the rest of the canal. The section from the inlet to this side-cut is described as.Lineal Part 2. Appellee’s plant is located on Lineal Part 1 which extends from the side-cut northeasterly to the outlet at Toledo, and is thus dependent for its supply of water on a continuous flow through Lineal Part 2.
The several leases were granted by the state, acting through its Board of Public Works, in 1895, 1901, two in 1903,. and T906. Each for a specified consideration or a stipulated rental, purported to grant for a period of thirty years, with privilege of. renewal, the right to take from the -canal specified amounts of water for hydraulic purposes.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit