Supreme Court of North Carolina December 30, 1929 (Harris v. . Comolli)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-12-1929
CoNNOR, J.
There was evidence at the trial of this action tending to sustain the allegation in the complaint, which was denied in the answer, that plaintiffs and defendants entered into the contract as alleged in the complaint. The performance of said contract by the plaintiffs, and its breach by the defendants are not controverted. There was evidence in support of the findings by the jury that plaintiffs are entitled to recover of the defendants, as damages for their breach of said contract the sum of $25,000.
Defendants’ contention upon their appeal to this Court is that plaintiffs have no right of action upon the contract alleged in the complaint, for that said contract upon its face is illegal because it is immoral and in violation of a sound public policy. Defendants contend that the con
*135
tract as alleged in tbe complaint contemplates a fraud on tbe receivers of tbe Eegal Marble Company, and on tbe court by wbicb tbe said receivers were appointed. Tbey rely upon tbe principle tbat any agreement wbicb tends to work a fraud or an imposition on a court of justice is void as against public policy. 13 C. J., p. 447, section 385.
Tbe contention of tbe defendants was presented to tbe trial court by tbeir demurrer
ore terms
to tbe complaint, and also by tbeir motion for judgment as of nonsuit at tbe close of. all tbe evidence. Defendants excepted to tbe refusal of tbe trial court to sustain tbeir demurrer
ore terms,
and also to its refusal to sustain tbeir motion for judgment as of nonsuit. Defendants also excepted to tbe instruction of tbe trial court to tbe jury tbat there was no evidence from wbicb tbe jury could find tbat tbe contract as alleged in tbe complaint is illegal or immoral, and tbat tbe jury should answer tbe second issue “No.” In this Court, defendants rely chiefly upon assignments of error based on these exceptions.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit