Ohio Court of Appeals March 4, 1929 (Kling v. George Ast Candy Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-03-1929

Hamilton, J.

This ease grows out of an automobile collision at a street intersection.

Adolph P. Kling, plaintiff in error, who was plaintiff in the court of common pleas, was driving his automobile on Kling avenue, which intersects with Harrison avenue. On coming into the intersection, he endeavored to turn south on Harrison avenue, toward the city of Cincinnati, when he came into collision with a Ford truck of the defendant in error, who was defendant in the court of common pleas. Kling received injuries to himself and his automobile, for which he brought suit in the court of common pleas. The trial of the case resulted in a verdict for the defendant, defendant in error here. From that verdict and judgment, Kling prosecutes error to this court.

There are several specifications of error, but one of which we consider important. It concerns a special charge given by the court. The special charge in question, charge No. 1-C, requested by the defendant, which the court gave, is as follows: “If the jury find that both plaintiff and defendant were

*179

operating their motor vehicles at the same time on Harrison avenue, and if they should also find that the path of the automobile operated by plaintiff intersected the path of. defendant’s truck, approaching from the right, then it was the duty of the plaintiff to yield the right' of way to defendant’s truck, at the intersection of the path of plaintiff’s automobile with the path of defendant’s truck, and if plaintiff failed so to do, and such failure contributed in any degree to the damages and injuries of which plaintiff complains, then your verdict must be for the defendant as to such damages and injuries.”

The giving of this special charge was objected to and exceptions taken, and is the chief ground for reversal presented here.

This charge is in direct conflict with the law as pronounced by the Supreme Court of Ohio in the case of

Heidle

v.

Baldwin,

118 Ohio St., 375, 161 N. E., 44, 58 A. L. R., 1186.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.