Ohio Court of Appeals December 23, 1929 (Cole v. Brown)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-12-1929
MIDDLETON, PJ.
It is contended by the plaintiff in error in this proceeding that the trial court erred in giving to the jury before argument at the request of Brown the following special instruction:
“I charge you as the law in this case that at the time plaintiff claims to have sustained the injuries set out in his petition that the Galena turnpike on which, defendant had placed sand and gravel, as set out in his answer, was a public highway of the State of Ohio, and
That the law of the State of Ohio (Section 13421-11 GQ.) stipulates that whoever unlawfully places any obstruction in or upon a public highway shall be fined, etc. Thus prohibiting s.uch unlawful obstruction in said highway.
That this law is one passed for the protection of the public and its violation is negligence per se.
And placing an obstruction in or upon said highway, which would interfere with the lawful travel upon such highway by the public, which obstruction is not guarded with due care to prevent danger to the public in such use, constitutes an unlawful placing of an obstruction upon a highway.”
It is contended that in this instruction the court undertook to set up a standard by which the jury should determine the negligence of Cole under the facts in evidence, and that such standard should have been left to the determination of the jury alone on the question of whether it constituted negligence on the part of Cole.
Section 13421-11 GC. provides as follows:
“Whoever unlawfully places .any obstruction in or upon a public highway shall be fined not more than fifty dollars nor less than five dollars.” .
The evidence shows that Cole placed the sand and graveljjpon the highway without any legal right so to do and that it extended from the west line of the highway *72across to the marked middle center of the paved road.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit