District Court, E.D. New York December 4, 1929, No. 2849 (Lundy v. United States Shipping Board Emergency Fleet Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-12-1929

GALSTON, District Judge.

This matter comes before the court on a motion to set aside a verdict in behalf of the plaintiff in the sum of $25,000, on the ground that the verdict was contrary to law, contrary to the evidence, contrary to the weight of evidence, and on the further ground that it'was grossly excessive.

The plaintiff is a young man, who at the age of 25 enlisted as a seaman with the defendant the United Gulf Steamship Company on a voyage to Manchester, England. The negligence complained of, and apparently not seriously controverted by the defendants, consisted in the directions of the officer in charge of a crew for the positioning of the gangplank when the vessel berthed at Manchester. It was during the negligent handling of the gangplank by the defendant that the plaintiff suffered the injuries complained of. He was hit on the side of the head, rendered unconscious, and according to the testimony of himself and three physicians, has *255lost the entire hearing of his left ear and part of the hearing of his right ear. In addition to loss of hearing, he testified to the impairment of his nervous system, and physicians also testified in support thereof.

The jury, of course, had the opportunity of measuring the credibility of the witnesses, as did the court. I was very much impressed by the testimony of the plaintiff, and particularly by the testimony of his physicians. Dr. Carr, the ear specialist, left no doubt in ruy mind that the plaintiff had lost the complete hearing of his left ear and had suffered a 30 per cent, loss of the hearing in his right ear. Whether the serious nervous trouble that followed the accident, and which persisted and persists, is wholly attributable to the accident itself may be doubted, but that the accident did contribute materially to the plaintiff’s nervotis condition I do not think can seriously be questioned.

The defendants’ witnesses, on the other hand, I did not find either impressive or convincing.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.