Supreme Court of Kansas November 9, 1929, No. 28,868 (State v. Harned)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-11-1929
The opinion of the court was delivered by
Hutchison, J.:
The defendant in this case was convicted of grand larceny, largely upon the evidence of an accomplice. The defendant appeals, urging three errors in particular: that the verdict is contrary to the evidence, that one of the jurors was disqualified, and newly discovered evidence. The discrepancies as to dates are relied upon strongly by appellant to show that the evidence of the state was unreliable and impossible. There appear to be only two positively fixed dates in the testimony of the state; one is January 7, 1928, when the wife of the accomplice sold the cowhide and received a check therefor, which she and her husband say was the hide taken from the stolen cow a week or ten days before and buried in a manure pile during that time; the other fixed date is January 8, 1928, a Sunday, when two hogs were missing from the Zeigler feed *121lot. A pool of blood was first noticed that morning, also blood on the fence and marks of dragging the hogs for a short distance on the ground. The conclusion of the defendant is that this blood and these marks were fresh, but the abstract of the evidence does not so state, although such is possible and perhaps more likely to have been recent than otherwise. The accessory witness testified that the two hogs and the cow were taken at the same time; that the hogs were killed there at the feed lot and the cow led to his place and there killed and dressed, where the hogs were also dressed. There is apparently an inconsistency. If the blood and dragging marks were fresh from the night before and the hogs and cow were taken and butchered the same night, the hide of the cow could not have been sold on the afternoon of January 7. But we are not told that the blood and dragging marks were not a day old, neither would the best judgment of observers be necessarily positive along that line.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit