Supreme Court of North Carolina September 24, 1930 (Jenkins v. . Floyd)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-09-1930

Clarkson, J.

Tbe sole question presented in tbis action: Tbe owner of land placed in buildings on bis land (1) a cotton gin, used for tbe purpose of ginning cotton for bimself and tbe public; (2) a corn mill, used for tbe purpose of grinding corn for bimself and tbe public, botb run by tbe same boiler. Are tbey fixtures, and do tbey become part of tbe realty? We tbink so as between vendor and vendee.

It was in evidence that tbe gin and corn mill were in separate buildings, but run by tbe same boiler. Tbe machinery was installed by J. J. Baird for tbe purpose not only of ginning bis own cotton and grinding bis own corn, but operated for tbe purpose also of ginning and grinding corn for other people. Tbe gin and corn mill were installed prior to tbe deed of 10 April, 1917, from J. J. Baird to bis wife, Mary E. Baird. Tbe positive evidence was to tbis effect, although there was some negative uncertain evidence that tbe corn mill was installed a little later than tbe date of tbe deed, but its probative force was not sufficient to be submitted to tbe jury.

It will be noted tbe question of fixtures arises between vendor and vendee.

In

Potter v. Cromwell,

40 N. Y., 287 (100 Am. Dec., p. 485), a portable grist mill was held to be a fixture and at execution sale went as part of tbe realty to tbe purchaser.

Daniels, J.,

at p. 297, said: “For it was annexed to tbe building erected upon tbe land, to be applied and appropriated to tbe business there to be carried on, with tbe design that it should be a permanent structure for use as a custom grist mill for the neighborhood existing about it.”

In

McKenna v. Hammond,

3 Hill Law, 331 (S. C.), (30 Am. Dec., 366),

Evans, J.,

said: “Tbe principle upon which that ease was decided, is, that whatsoever is erected upon land as a means of enjoying it, is a fixture; but whatever is intended for tbe purpose of carrying on a trade which has no necessary connection with tbe use of tbe land, is a mere chattel, and belongs to tbe administrator.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.