South Dakota Supreme Court June 24, 1930, File No. 6652 (Commercial Credit Co. v. Nissen)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-06-1930
BROW'N, P. J.
In this action on five negotiable promissory notes for $1,072 each, defendant pleaded want of consideration as a defense. The case has appeared in our reports on three former occasions. 43 S. D. 564, 181 N. W. 99; 49 S. D. 303, 207 N. W. 61, 51 A. L. R. 287; and 51 S. D. 357, 213 N. W. 943, 51 A. L. R. 287. On the last occasion it was remanded to the trial court to determine “when, plaintiff paid the seventy-five per cent of the purchase price and when knowledge of defendant’s defense came to plaintiff.”
On Dcember 15, 1917, defendant, then in business in Aberdeen, S. D., made a contract with Interstate Tractor Company of Waterloo, Iowa, for the purchase of fifty tractors to be shipped to him during the months of January, February, and March, 1918. For the purchase price he executed to the tractor company fifty notes for $1,072 each, some due in six month and some in six and one-half months. The five notes involved in this suit are part of the fifty. The tractor company agreed not to negotiate any note until it ihad shipped a tractor therefor; defendant got no tractor for any of the notes in suit. ’Since the notes were therefore negotiated in breach of faith, the burden is on plaintiff to prove that it acquired title to them, as a holder in due course. Rev. Code 1919, §§ I759> I7f>3- The following is a summary of the evidence on that point: Plaintiff is a corporation engaged in the business of dealing in commercial paper, largely in the purchase of notes and other evidence of indebtedness from manufacturers and jobbers. Its principal place of business is at Baltimore, Md. In April, 1918, Alexander E. D'uncan, one of its officers, in response to a *160request of the tractor company that plaintiff consider the purchase of some notes of customers of the tractor company, went to Waterloo, Iowa, and there arranged to purchase from Interstates Tractor Company notes of their customers aggregating about $100,000.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit