Supreme Court of Kansas January 11, 1930, No. 29,066 (Harvey v. Majors)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-01-1930
The opinion of the court was delivered by
Marshall, J.:
This is an action on a bond given to secure a restraining order and temporary injunction enjoining the plaintiff from taking the evidence of a certain witness in an action for workmen’s compensation. Judgment was rendered in favor of the plaintiff, and the defendants appeal.
The action in which the bond was given was one in which William Harvey was plaintiff and Eldridge & Majors Packing Company and J. J. Majors were defendants. The plaintiff desired to take the deposition of defendant J. J. Majors, who obtained the restraining order and temporary injunction, and with the defendant, the Maryland Casualty Company, signed the bond to obtain that order. The restraining order and temporary injunction were afterward dissolved, and this action was commenced.
The defendants contend that the court had no jurisdiction of the action in which the bond was given. The nature of the action *557has been stated. On the trial of that action it appeared that the defendants therein were willing to arbitrate. An arbitrator was appointed, an award was made, a motion to modify the award was denied, an appeal was taken to this court, and the judgment was affirmed. (Harvey v. Eldridge & Majors Packing Co., 128 Kan. 403, 278 Pac. 16.) The defendants rely on the principle that a judgment by a court without jurisdiction of'the subject matter is a nullity and cite a number of authorities to support that principle. The district court did have jurisdiction to determine the matter that was before it, but because the defendants in the compensation case showed that they were willing to arbitrate as • the law directed, the action was not tried. The plaintiff was enjoined from taking the deposition of J. J. Majors, irrespective of the jurisdiction of the court to try the action for compensation.
In 32 C. J.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit