California Court of Appeal July 9, 1931, Docket No. 6666. (Scott v. Shaw)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-07-1931
BISHOP, J.,
pro
tem.
Andrew Scott, aged four years, was struck by an automobile driven by defendant on a public highway in Los Angeles city. By his guardian
ad litem,
Andrew brought suit to recover for the injuries he sustained, and in a separate action his mother sought reimbursement for the expenses she incurred because of his injuries. Pursuant to stipulation, the actions were consolidated and proceeded to trial. From a judgment of nonsuit and an order denying them new trials both plaintiffs appeal. Because there is evidence which would warrant the jury in finding that the defendant drove negligently and that his negligence was the proximate cause of the accident, the motion for a nonsuit should not have been granted.
From the evidence the jury may well have seen this picture: Andrew and his nurse with his little sister Jean, who is just out of school for the noon recess, are walking south along the east side of Burlington Avenue, between Acacia and Maryland Streets. Jean, six years old, runs across Burlington Avenue to the opposite side. A few seconds more and Andrew breaks away from his nurse, runs around the end of an automobile parked obliquely to the curb and out into the street. When fifteen feet beyond the automobile he hesitates, then goes on, his course being south of a direct line across the street. Burlington Avenue, between Acacia and Maryland Streets, drops toward the south at a grade of 7.8 per cent. Down Burlington Avenue the defendant is driving a Studebaker sedan, first seen by the nurse when it is just south of Acacia Street, regarded again when about forty feet north of the path of the boy
*402
and then as it shuts out the boy from her sight. Its speed, the jury could believe, was twenty-eight to thirty miles an hour from the time it was first noticed until forty feet from the boy’s path. At the time the car driven by defendant was forty feet away from Andrew, he was at the point fifteen feet beyond the parked car.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit