Indiana Court of Appeals June 5, 1931, No. 13,742. (Estes v. Anderson Oil Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-06-1931

Kime, J.

A rehearing having been granted after a

per curiam

affirmance, this case is again before the court.

Suit was brought by the appellant against Anderson Oil Company and William R. Wood to recover for personal injuries arising Out of an automobile collision. At the close of the plaintiff’s case, appellee Anderson Oil Company filed a motion for an instructed verdict. This motion was sustained and the jury was instructed that at the proper time they would be instructed to return a verdict for Anderson Oil Company. The trial proceeded as to William R. Wood, the jury returning a verdict as against him for $5,500. Motion for a new trial was overruled and judgments entered on the verdicts. Vacation appeal properly assigning as error the action of the trial court in directing a verdict and its refusal to grant a new trial for newly discovered evidence.

Appellant contends that there existed between the appellees the relation of principal and agent, master and

*368

servant, employer and employee or that the doctrine of

respondeat superior

applies.

The evidence, as disclosed by appellant’s brief, which is unchallenged by the appellee, shows that, immediately after the accident, appellee Wood made a telephone call. That, immediately thereafter, a Mr. Jones of the Anderson Oil Company came to the scene of the accident. The evidence further shows that Mr. Jones was .president of the Anderson Oil Company. That the truck had a sign “Anderson Oil Co.” on it. in several places.

Fleischman

v.

Ice and Fuel Co.

(1910), 148 Mo. App. 117, 127 S. W. 660;

Polk Sanitary Milk Co.

v.

Qualiza

(1930), 92 Ind. App. 72, 172 N. E. 576. . The name of Wood was not on the truck. Wood said, in answer to a question: “Probably three years, seems to me as though

I worked for them

two years.” He was there referring to the Anderson Oil Company. The Anderson Oil Company fixed the price at which he (Wood) could sell the gasoline.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.