Supreme Court of Iowa June 20, 1931, No. 40857. (Hanby v. Snyder)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-06-1931

Evans, J.

We look to the petition for the facts in the case. The petition herein was filed November 28, 1930, For more than

*846

ten years preceding, the defendant, Mrs. Snyder, had been the holder of a life estate in certain real property involved herein. During such period of time she was debtor to the plaintiff upon a note signed by her with her husband. In August 1930 the plaintiff began a personal action against Mrs. Snyder and her husband upon said note and sued out a writ of attachment therein and levied said writ upon the life estate of Mrs. Snyder. In September 1930 he obtained judgment confirming his attachment and awarding special execution under which the property was sold to the plaintiff on November 20, 1930. Long prior to the beginning of the attachment suit, Mrs. Snyder had suffered default in the payment of taxes on the property for the years 1923 and 1924 and the same was sold for such taxes at tax sale. The purchaser at such tax sale is not disclosed in the pleading. It is averred that the defendant Mrs. Brown acquired such tax certificate. It is assumed in argument, but not averred in the pleading, that Mrs. Brown as certificate-holder has paid the annual taxes ever since the tax sale. Pending the attachment proceedings, Mrs. Brown took the statutory steps to mature a tax title. The objective of this suit is to enjoin the issuance of a tax deed to Mrs. Brown. The plaintiff’s first ground for relief is predicated upon the foregoing facts.

The petition further alleges that in October 1930 Mrs. Snyder and her husband “executed a quit claim deed for their interest in the said premises to the defendant Sarah P. Brown”.

As his first ground of relief the plaintiff contends that Mrs. Snyder conspired with Mrs. Brown (who was her mother) to defraud the plaintiff by permitting the mother to acquire title to her life estate and by neglecting the payment of the taxes accordingly. The second ground urged is that the quit claim deed executed by Mrs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.