Tennessee Supreme Court December 19, 1931 (Loring v. McGinness)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-12-1931
Mr. Justice Swiggart
delivered the opinion of the Court.
Chapter 558 of the Private Acts of 1931 is a road law for DeKalb County. Complainant, member and chairman of the Central Eoad Commission, under Private Acts
1921,
chapter 364, prays a decree that the Act of
*546
1931 is nnconstitntional and void. The chancellor ruled against him, on demurrer, and complainant has appealed.
The Act is made to apply to DeKalb County by population classification. It is obvious that it can be made to apply to no other county, and is therefore to be treated as if limited in application to that county by name. Since it affects the county only in its governmental capacity, it is npt unconstitutional because of its restricted local application.
Stokes
v.
Dobbins,
158 Tenn., 350;
State ex rel.
v.
Turnpike Co.,
133 Tenn., 446.
Changes made by the Act of 1981 in the system of road construction and maintenance, theretofore controlled by the Act of 1921, are substantial and real, and not merely colorable as in
Smith
v.
Sells,
156 Tenn., 539. The complainant was therefore not legislated out of office in such manner as to violate any constitutionally vested right.
Haggard
v.
Gallien,
157 Tenn., 269;
Goetz
v.
Smith,
152 Tenn., 462;
Holland
v.
Parker,
159 Tenn., 306.
The Act of 1981 directs that the control and management of the county roads “shall be vested in a county road commission, . . . and a county road supervisor employed by the commission.” The commissioners are to he elected by popular vote, and are empowered to “employ” the supervisor under section 5, which is:
“That the supervisor herein provided for shall be a citizen and resident of the county and a person of good character and reputation and above the age of twenty-one. He shall be employed by the Commission for a term of - not less than 2 years, and said employment cannot be revoked by the Commission, except for good cause.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit