West Virginia Supreme Court October 27, 1931, 6953 (Snyder v. Abbott)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-10-1931

Litz, President :

This is a suit by the administrator (P.

W.

Snyder) and heirs at law of McHenry Abbott (who died June 19, 1926), against the widow, Blanche Abbott, to cancel a decree pro confesso in her favor, entered in a former suit by her against the present plaintiffs to recover her distributive share in the estate, because the service of process was accepted on behalf of the defendants therein by an attorney without authority.

The bill prays that the decree, complained of, be set aside, and the cause reheard. The trial court refused to vacate the decree in favor of Mrs. Abbott on the ground that plaintiffs had not shown a meritorious defense to her claim; and they appealed.

She married the deceased June 11, 1925, after nursing him in. illness, upon his promise (as she claims) to make her a gift marriage of three thousand dollars. According to her contention, shortly after the marriage, in compliance with her

*202

.request that he fulfill his promise, he placed the money in his room, where she later secured it with his consent. She relies upon his statements thereafter, detailed by two witnesses, that he had promised her a gift before marriage, and her subsequent relations with him. Plaintiffs, on the other hand, contend that she obtained the money surreptitiously, without his consent. The basis of this claim is an alleged statement made by Abbott soon after the money came into her possession that it had been taken without his knowledge. It is conceded that subsequently he gave her other moneys at numerous times and that she attended him in sickness and managed their domestic affairs. Cordial relations for the most part seem to have existed between them until his death.

Plaintiffs not only contend that she should be charged with the three thousand dollars (more than her distributive share), but also rely upon a writing signed by her, dated “January 25, 1927, releasing her interest in the estate.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.