Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit March 9, 1931, No. 206 (Berwind White Coal Mining Co. v. City of New York)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-03-1931

AUGUSTUS N. HAND, Circuit Judge.

The libelant, owner of the coal barge Eureka No. 5, was requested by respondent Transatlántica Italiana to deliver a barge-load of bunker coal to its steamship Guiseppe Verdi, which was lying on the north side of Pier 75, North River, Borough of Manhattan. . Libellant accordingly ordered its tug Admiral Dewey to tow the barge to the place. This was done on April 30, 1926, and the barge was moored astern of the Guiseppe Verdi to wait until some of the libellant’s other coal barges were unloaded, before discharging her cargo on the steamer. Libellant had no particular knowledge of the condition of the pier, though it had previously at times had its barges towed there to steamers of the French Line. The Eureka No. 5 was moored in the 'slip astern of the Guiseppe Verdi and bow-in. She was in good condition when the bargee left her for the night. The next morning she was found settled on the bottom of the slip. The bottom of the barge was penetrated by an oak pile which was sticking through her planking on the starboard side. The portion of the pile which was fast in the barge had apparently broken from the end of one of the fender piles of the pier. It was about two feet in length and from 12 to 14-inches in diameter. The remainder of the pile was something like 24 feet long and was still sticking in the mud of the slip when discovered. The end of the pile had evidently been under water and the barge had settled upon it with the ebb of the tide.

The fespondent Transatlántica Italiana had a permit from the City of New York (the owner of the premises) to use the pier for April 30, and had leased it for a term beginning May 1. There was some testimony that the break in the piece of the pile found embedded in the barge was new, but this evidence was of slight weight, as bearing upon the length of time during which the pile had been a hidden danger to navigation.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.