Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit December 4, 1931, Nos. 4529-4531 (Phelps v. Commissioner)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-12-1931

SPARKS, Circuit Judge

(after stating the facts as above).

There being no controversy over the facts, the sole question presented is whether the amounts, received by petitioners should be considered, for the purposes of taxation, as dividends under section 201, Revenue Act of 1921, c. 136, 42 Stat. 227, 228, as claimed by respondent, or as gains derived from sales of property under section 202 of the same statute (42 Stat. 229), as claimed by petitioners. So much of those sections as are pertinent are set forth in the margin.2

If, under the facts stated, we are hound by the plain meaning of the language employed in the resolution referred to in the statement of facts, then of course the transactions in controversy should be considered as sales, for that is what the resolution termed them, and pursuant thereto there was an exchange of- stock for money. But in all relations of life it oftentimes happens that the thing done speaks so audibly that equity is prevented from hearing the language of the parties, and will classify the aet by its real name rather than by the name which the interested parties have given it. In such instances the substance of the transaction will control the form, and the Board therefore was warranted in considering both form and substance in arriving at its conclusion. United States v. Phellis, 257 U. S. 156, 42 S. Ct. 63, 66 L. Ed. 180; United States v. Klausner (C. C. A.) 25 F.(2d) 608.

That taxing statutes cannot be intentionally circumvented by anticipatory arrangements and contracts is settled by the principle laid down in Lucas v. Earl, 281 U. S. 111, 50 S. Ct. 241, 74 L. Ed. 731. It is obvious that if the stockholders of the W. L. Phelps Company intended to, and in fact did, liquidate wholly or partially by distributing its assets to its stockholders and taking up their stock, the earnings and profits so received by them would be governed by section 201, supra.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.