Appellate Court of Illinois October 21, 1931, Gen. No. 34,823 (National Bond & Investment Co. v. Moss)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-10-1931

Mr. Justice Friend

delivered the opinion of the court.

Plaintiff filed suit in replevin to recover possession of a Marmon automobile of the alleged value of $1,000. Upon demand made by the bailiff of the municipal court, Charles P. Moss, doing business as the Moss Auto Sales, defendant herein, refused to deliver up the chattel, whereupon plaintiff, by leave of court, filed a statement of claim in trover. . Trial was had before the court without a jury, resulting in a finding for the defendant and the entry of a judgment that the plaintiff take nothing by its suit.

The essential facts, as to which there is substantially no dispute, disclose that on August 19, 1929, J. A. Jacobson, trading as Jacobson Auto Company, sold the car in question to Christ Johnson on a time payment plan, taking from him to evidence his deferred payments a promissory note for $1,107.48, payable in instalments of $92.29 each monthly thereafter, and a chattel mortgage on said automobile to secure said note. The chattel mortgage was properly executed and filed for record in Wisconsin. Shortly after the Jacobson Auto Company took said note and mortgage it sold and delivered them, for a valuable consideration, to plaintiff. Plaintiff is an automobile finance company with offices in Racine, Wisconsin, Chicago and elsewhere, whose business is that of purchasing from automobile dealers notes, contracts. and other papers evidencing time sales of automobiles by such dealers.

Johnson paid to plaintiff the September and October instalments on the note, but defaulted on the subsequent payments. After acquiring said automobile Johnson drove it around in the vicinity of Racine, Wisconsin, until about November 5, 1929, when he came to Chicago with the car and traded it to the defendant, Moss, for two other cars at a valuation of $841. Within five days thereafter the defendant, Moss, sold the car for an undisclosed amount.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.