Supreme Court of Alabama January 14, 1932, 6 Div. 903. (Crisp v. First Nat. Bank of Birmingham)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-01-1932
FOSTER, J.
This is a bill filed by appellee as a creditor of A. Crisp to set aside a conveyance of his property consisting of a stock of goods, as a fraud upon its rights as such. ' It alleges that complainant “is the owner of and holder in due course of the following unpaid promissory note.” It also shows that the note was payable to the order of the Bank of Ensley and indorsed by it. Appellant claims that such allegations do not specify the facts on which the ownership is averred, and that such ownership as alleged is but the conclusion of the pleader. It may be conceded that both the legal and equitable owners of commercial paper must be before the court of equity (Chat. Sav. Bank v. Crawford, 206 Ala. 530, 91 So. 316; McGhee v. Importers’ & Traders’ Nat. Bank, 93 Ala. 192, 9 So. 734), and that, when the bill or complaint shows that a note is commercial paper and payable to the order of the payee, the complainant must) have title by indorsement, or make the legal owner a party (Clayton v. Bank, 204 Ala. 64, 85 So. 271; Sample v. Bank, 200 Ala. 578, 76 So. 936); but the allegations of the bill which we have stated sufficiently show such title by indorsement. Clayton v. Bank, supra; Sandlin v. Maury Nat. Bank, 210 Ala. 349, 98 So. 190; sections 9077, 9078, Code.
The allegation that Crisp attempted to convey his stock of merchandise and in the same paragraph that it “was conveyed or purported to be conveyed to respondent R. Q. Blanton,” is not subject to demurrer for failure to allege a conveyance. Aside from the fact that the form of the allegation was doubtless dictated by a cautious effort not to admit the effectiveness of the conveyance, the statute in terms applies to an attempt -to transfer or convey. Section 7342.
Allegation that the conveyance of the property was voluntary and without consideration is sufficient averment by an existing creditor to vacate it without regard to any other circumstance. McCrory v. Donald, 192 Ala. 312, 68 So. 306; London v. G. L.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit