New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division April 1, 1932 (In Re Estate of Farrell)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-04-1932
Buchanan, Vice-Ordinary.
Theresa Earrell, widow of decedent, and one of the residuary legatees under his will, excepted to the account of Otto S. Martin, executor, and appeals from the order of the orphans court overruling the exceptions.
The first exception seeks to surcharge the accountant in respect of the capital stock of the Trenton Dairy Company held by decedent at his death — for which the executor charges himself with $15,980.
By the will of decedent the executor was directed to appoint three disinterested persons who should appraise the stock in question, and report the appraisement in writing
*261
to the executor. Option was given to James Specht and Margaret Specht (nephew and niece of testator) to purchase the stock at the appraised figure, and if such option were not exercised the executor was to sell the stock in such manner as he deemed advisable. The proceeds of sale in either event were to go to the
corpus
of decedent’s estate.
The appraisers were appointed and appraised the stock (eighty-five shares at $188 per share) at $15,980, and so reported. The nephew and niece exercised the option, took the stock and paid the executor the $15,980 — the figure charged in his account.
Appellant contends that the valuation fixed by the appraisers was only about half the actual value of the stock; the exception charges that the true value was at least $30,000; that the appraisers “unlawfully rejected certain elements of value” in making the appraisement; that the executor should be charged with the $30,000 instead of $15,980.
Admittedly the appraisers in arriving at the value of the stock, allowed nothing for any asset of the company in the way of good will. Appellant contends that the testimony taken on the hearing on the exceptions proves that the corporation did have an asset of good will, and that it therefore should have been taken into account by the appraisers in the fixing of the valuation.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit