Supreme Court of North Carolina June 15, 1932 (Bolich v. Prudential Insurance Co. of America)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-06-1932
BeogkdeN, J.
Does the depression or unprecedented scarcity of money for ordinary transactions or enforced stagnation of the real estate market constitute an equity sufficient to warrant a court in restraining the exercise of the power of sale in a .deed of trust ?
The power of a court of equity to restrain sales of real estate made in pursuance of the terms of a mortgage or deed of trust is undoubted, and the decisions of this Court disclose that the restraining power of equity in proper cases has been frequently exercised. However, the exercise of the beneficent powers of equity has usually been based upon allegations of fraud, restraint, oppression, usury, mistake or other facts disclosing unconscionable advantage. Unless such elements are alleged, the courts have refused to ,stay the exercise of the power of sale in a mortgage or deed of trust when all the necessary requisites of a valid sale have been observed and pursued.
Lumber Co. v. Conrades,
195 N. C., ,626, 143 S. E., 138. It does not appear that this Court has heretofore discussed the particular question involved in this appeal. However, there are some old cases in other jurisdictions directly in point. For example, in 1871, the Virginia Court considered the question in
Muller v. Bayly,
62 Va., 521. The Court said: “Then, what other ground of equity is there in the bill? Only the allegations that the time is unpropitious for a sale or was when the bill was filed; that money was scarce, and that owing to the large amount of the cash payment required, the sale, if made as advertised by the trustee Bayly, would be attended with great if not irreparable loss and injury to the wife and her children. Certainly these allegations can afford no just
*792
ground for enjoining tbe sale.” To tbe same effect is tbe declaration in
Lipscomb v. N. T. Life Ins. Co.,
39 S. W., 465.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit