Superior Court of Pennsylvania March 17, 1932, Appeal 21 (Cheltenham & Abington Sewerage Co. v. P. S. C.)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-03-1932
Opinion by
Parker, J.,
This case comes to us on an appeal from The Public Service Commission. The Cheltenham
&
Abington Sewerage Company, organized under the provisions of the General Corporation Act of 1874, as amended by the Act of 1893, P. L. 476, filed tariffs increasing the rates for sanitary sewage service and private storm water drainage service, and creating new charges to municipalities for surface drainage. Complaints were filed with the commission by various individuals and by the Townships of Abington and Cheltenham, Montgomery County. The commission reduced the rates fixed for service through the sanitary systems and with reference to the storm water system held that the sewerage company had failed “to show ownership or possession of these storm water drains so as to justify charges for their use.” By a stipulation filed, the scope of the appeal was confined to the legality of the commission’s action “insofar as it undertook to find and determine that the storm water systems were not the property of the sewerage company.” The prime question involved is whether the appellant was the owner of certain surface drainage or “storm water” sewer systems used in performing a public service.
The questions involved arose out of real estate development enterprises. In 1897, William L. Elkins owned a small tract of land in what was then called Ogontz Park, now Elkins Park, in Cheltenham Township, and Mr. Elkins and P. A. B. Widener owned a larger tract of several hundred acres located in the vicinity of Glenside Station, Abington and Cheltenham Townships. The former is referred to as the Elkins Park district and the latter as the Glenside district.
*229
Elkins and Widener having decided to develop these tracts of land by laying them out in suburban lots for residence purposes, entered into some arrangement for their development, the details of which do not appear, with W. T. B. Roberts, a real estate operator.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit