Tennessee Supreme Court April 30, 1932 (Dearing v. N., C. & St. L. Ry.)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-04-1932
Mr. Justice Swiggart
delivered tlie opinion of the Court.
This is an ejectment suit to gain possession of approximately 1100 acres of land in Franklin County. The complainant, Bearing, unsuccessful in the Chancery Court, appealed to the Court of Appeals, where the decree of the Chancellor was reversed and a decree awarded him. The defendant’s petition for the writ of
certiorari
has been granted and argument of counsel has been heard. '
The land in controversy was purchased by the Railway in 1869, and operations were conducted thereon for cutting timber to provide fuel for its wood-burning locomotives. Certain buildings were erected on the land in aid of those operations, but these fell into disuse and were destroyéd, and the Railway was unable to prove title by adverse possession for seven years. Such defense, presented by the answer, was abandoned in the Chancery Court, and the case was heard and determined by the Chancellor on the proof as to the legal title of each party, deraigned to conflicting grants issued by the State of Tennessee.
Complainant’s title is founded upon grant number 5978, dated March 15, 1838; issued pursuant to entry number 90, dated August 19, 1837, including 5,000' acres.
Defendant’s title is founded upon grant number 7000, dated August 7, 1839; issued pursuant to entry number 2307, dated February 6, 1837, including 2,000 acres.
Defendant’s entry 2307 is of earlier date than the
*363
entry upon which complainant’s grant was issued, and therefore, although complainant’s grant is of earlier date than defendant’s grant, the title founded upon the younger grant and older entry must prevail if the entry can he held to he the inception of the title.
We quote the well established rule of law from
Southern Coal & Iron Co.
v.
Schwoon,
145 Tenn., 191, 235-236, 239 S. W., 398: “It has become elementary that superiority of title is to be found with the holder of the title prior in date.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit