Supreme Court of New Jersey March 16, 1932 (Newell v. Workmen's Compensation Bureau)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-03-1932

Per Curiam.

The workmen’s compensation bureau made an award in favor of Burton Kiple, for injuries alleged to have been sustained by accident, on December 21st, 1928, whilst Kiple was helping to carry a can of ashes from the cellar to the main floor of the employer’s place of business and in the course of his work. The testimony was to the effect that while so doing he injured his back and was compelled to cease work.

The doctor who treated the petitioner below testified that there had been a severe or twisting strain, which injured certain vertebrae; that he was unable to work. He died on February 10th, 1931.

Two doctors for the defendant testified that there was an atrophy of the spine, by the closing of the joints between the vertebrae. They testified that, while the condition was probably of long standing, it would have been aggravated by a severe strain.

*406A fellow workman of Kiple, one Leone, testified that petitioner was helping him carry a can of ashes up the cellar stairs when something happened to Kiple that caused him to-almost drop the can; that Kiple gave immediate evidence of having suffered an injury'to his back.

The petitioner’s daughter testified that his condition grew progressively worse after the injury.

TJnder the proofs we think the compensation bureau was-justified in its determination that Kiple met with an accident arising out of and in the course of his employment. Atchison v. Colgate & Co., 128 Atl. Rep. 598; 3 N. J. Mis. R. 451.

Prosecutor contends that the testimony of Peter Leone and Lavinia Kiple was incompetent. Certainly much, if not all, of their testimony was competent. But there was no objection to its admission and hence there was no error in its admission.

The third point is that the award covered too long a period of time. The proof was that he was fully incapacitated from December 28th, 1928, to the date of his death on February 10th, 1931, and this was the period covered by the award.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.