Supreme Court of the United States November 6, 1933, 50 (Shepard v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-11-1933
*97
Mr. Justice Cardozo
delivered the opinion of the Court.
The petitioner, Charles A. Shepard, a major in the medical corps of the United States army, has been, convicted of the murder of his wife, Zenana Shepard, at Fort Riley, Kansas, a United States military reservation. The jury having qualified their verdict by adding thereto the words “without capital punishment” (18 U.S.C. §567), the defendant was sentenced to imprisonment for life. The judgment of the United States District Court has been affirmed by the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, One of the judges of that court dissenting. 62 F. (2d) 683; 64 F. (2d) 641, A writ of certiorari brings the case here.
The crime is charged to have been committed by poisoning the victim with bichloride of mercury. The defendant was in love with another woman, and wished to make her his wife. There is circumstantial evidence
*98
to sustain a finding by the jury that to win himself his freedom he turned to poison and murder. Even so, guilt was contested and conflicting inferences are possible. The defendant asks us to hold that by the acceptance of incompetent evidence the scales were weighted to his prejudice and in the end to his undoing.
The evidence complained of was offered by the Government in rebuttal when the trial was nearly over. On May'2-2, 1929, there was a conversation in the absence of the defendant between Mrs. Shepard, then ill in bed, and Clara Brown, her nurse. The patient asked the nurse to go to the closet in the defendant’s room and bring a bottle of whisky that would be found upon a shelf. When the bottle was produced, she said that this was the liquor she had taken just before collapsing. She asked whether enough was left to make a test for the presence of poison, insisting that, the smell and taste were strange. And then she added the words “ Dr. Shepard has poisoned me.”
' The conversation was proved twice.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit