Supreme Court of Alabama March 23, 1933, 6 Div. 300. (Nunez v. Borden)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-03-1933

FOSTER, Justice.

When a claim of exemption is made by a judgment debtor to funds in the hands of a garnishee in a garnishment writ issued on such judgment, he must accompany his claim with a “statement setting forth the personal property, choses in action and money, and the location and value thereof,” duly verified. Section 7908, Code. “The purpose of the requirement is to prevent the defendant, while claiming the money garnished as exempt, secreting other personal property, money, or choses in action subject to his debts, and which may be reached by appropriate legal process.” Decatur Mercantile Co. v. Deford, 93 Ala. 347, 349, 9 So. 454, 455.

A 'statute should be given effect according to its purpose manifested by its language ' and other rules of construction. The court is often not controlled by the literal language of the statute, but by its meaning when properly interpreted, though outside of such literal meaning. City of Birmingham v. Southern Express Co., 164 Ala. 529, 51 So. 159 ; Cocciola et al. v. Wood-Dickerson Supply Co., 136 Ala. 532, 537, 33 So. 856, 857; Davis & Co. v. Thomas, 154 Ala. 279, 45 So. 897; Graham v. City of Mobile, 17 Ala. App. 19, 81 So. 355; 59 Corpus Juris, 964 et seq.

In the case of Young v. Hubbard, 102 Ala. 373, 14 So. 569, the court was dealing with the foregoing feature of that statute. A claim of exemption and statement of the personalty verified, as required by statute, had been filed in court January 19, 1893, in another case. The garnishee, in March, 1893, answered indebted in the pending case, and defendant, on March 18t'h, filed in that case the same claim and statement which he had previously filed in the other case without reverification. The court in holding it insufficient said: .“His [the defendant’s] rights depend upon the amount of property he owns to day, at the moment of his solemn statement under oath, not upon what he had last year or last month or yesterday.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.