Supreme Court of Alabama October 5, 1933, 8 Div. 451. (Proctor v. Coffey)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-10-1933
*320
FOSTER, Justice.
This is an appeal from a judgment setting aside a verdict and judgment in favor of defendant, in a suit under the homicide statute (Code 1923, § 5696). Plaintiff’s intestate was riding on the back seat of the car at the invitation of defendant. That situation required of defendant an exercise of ordinary care not to injure him. The counts separately charged negligent injury and willful and wanton injury, causing death.
There were pleas of contributory negligence for the failure to protest after knowledge of the negligent and dangerous operation of the car. They were held good as to the simple negligence count and bad as to the willful or wanton count.
'The evidence tended to show negligence of defendant, or even wantonness as an inference from the facts, and also the contributory negligence of plaintiff’s intestate.-
The court assigned no ground as that on which it acted in granting the motion. One ground was that the verdict was contrary to the great weight of the evidence. The ruling might have been based on that ground. We do not wish to say that, as an original proposition such would be our ruling as to the evidence, but we cannot reverse the judgment on such a ruling unless we think that it was clearly wrong. We cannot here so affirm. A discussion of the evidence would not be appropriate. The judgment of the court in that respect can-hot therefore be reversed. But since thereby another trial is called for, we think that for that purpose we should pass upon those other grounds of the motion which show questions likely to arise on another trial.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit