Supreme Court of Alabama January 26, 1933, 3 Div. 43. (State v. Praetorians)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-01-1933
GARDNER, Justice.
Appellee is a fraternal life insurance company authorized and doing business in Alabama, and by this proceeding the state seeks the collection of what is designated by the parties a license or excise tax attempted to be imposed under the latter provisions of section 8505, Code 1923. As originally enacted (General Acts 1911, page 700, § 30), this statute contained only the exemption feature as follows: “Every fraternal benefit society organized or licensed under this act, is hereby declared to be a charitable and benevolent in
*260
stitution, and all of its funds shall he exempt from all and every State, county, district, municipal and school tax, other than taxes on real estate and office equipment.”
In the process of codifying this particular statute there was added by the code committee the following provision: “But whenever any fraternal benefit society issues policies of life insurance based on the adequate rate plan as provided by the statutes of any state, or issues any health or accident insurance contracts or policies, then such societies shall pay to the state one per cent of all premiums on such policies or contracts issued to citizens of this state.”
This new provision was included in, and adopted as a part of the Code, and appears in its completed form as section 8505.
Numerous objections on constitutional grounds are aimed at this feature of the statute. All objections save two will be laid out of view, and we .gather from argument here presented these two are the grounds upon which the trial court rested his decision that this feature of the statute was invalid. They will be briefly considered. The first relates to section 221 of our Constitution, which prohibits the Legislature from permitting any person, firm, or corporation to pay a privilege, license, or other tax to the state and relieves him or it from the payment of all other privilege and license taxes in the state.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit