Michigan Supreme Court August 29, 1933, Docket No. 47, Calendar No. 36,931. (Gauss v. First Wayne National Bank)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-08-1933

Potter, J.

October 23, 1931, plaintiff filed a bill for specific performance of a written contract, a copy of which appears in the margin,

*

and for an

*235

order directing defendant bank to convey and deliver to bim the bonds and notes which he designated. The bank filed an answer in the nature of a cross-bill naming all of the persons who executed as purchasers the contract as defendants. The answer and cross-bill of the bank denied plaintiff’s right to select the bonds and notes designated by him, because such selection by plaintiff would affect the rights of the bank and other guarantors. By

*236

way of cross-bill it asked tbe court apportion tbe bonds and notes among tbe parties to tbe agreement,

*237

in accordance with the amount of their subscriptions ; that if the court did not apportion such bonds, then the bank be authorized to sell the same, the net proceeds to be paid to the bank, and if the amount realized was insufficient to pay it the balance due, $194,000, together with interest and expenses, the deficit be charged against the subscribers to said agreement who were made cross-defendants, in proportion to their subscriptions as appearing in the agreement; that the signers of the contract as purchasers be decreed to pay thq balance due and defendant have execution therefor. Mr. Van Paris, administrator of the estate of Axel E. Michelson, deceased, filed,a motion to dismiss the proceedings, because the contract was not capable of specific performance, but was void for uncertainty and incompleteness. This is conceded, but defendant bank argues that if the contract is incomplete it should be reformed so as to make it complete. But reformation of written contracts is based upon equitable principles, making the written contract conform to the real agreement between the parties; supplying provisions which should have been inserted, or omitting therefrom provisions which were inserted. The basis of reformation is fraud or mistake.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.