Michigan Supreme Court May 16, 1933, Docket No. 52, Calendar No. 36,993. (Dades v. Central Mutual Auto Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-05-1933

North, J.

Plaintiff on default for nonappearance took judgment against defendant for $923.50. Within six months after entry of judgment defendant entered its appearance specially and moved to vacate the judgment and set aside the default. From the order of the circuit judge denying the motion, defendant has perfected this appeal in the nature of mandamus.

In part, defendant’s motion to vacate the judgment and set aside the default is based upon the failure of the officer serving process to show by his return that service was upon the defendant, the Central Mutual Auto

Insurance

Company, and that instead the return shows service upon the Central Mutual Auto

Bales

Company. Pending the hearing of defendant’s motion, a motion was made by

*262

plaintiff to amend the return of service. The two motions were heard simultaneously. We have repeatedly held that unless the files of the court disclose proper proof of service of process a default entered is irregular; and the test is the condition of the file “on the day of default.” This is true notwithstanding service has been actually and lawfully made.

Whirl

v.

Reiner,

229 Mich. 114. To the same effect as being controlling in the instant case, see

Stanczuk

v.

Pfent,

231 Mich. 689;

Westlawn Cemetery Ass’n

v.

Wayne Circuit Judge,

238 Mich. 119;

Standard Oil Co.

v.

Brukwinski,

242 Mich. 49.

In behalf of appellee it is urged that it was within the power of the circuit judge to permit amendment of the return under the following statutory provisions:

“All returns made by any sheriff or other officer, or by any court or subordinate tribunal, to any court, may be amended

in matter of form

by the court to which such returns shall be made, in their discretion, as well before as after judgment.” 3 Comp. Laws 1929, § 14147.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.