Oregon Supreme Court January 24, 1933 (Kalafate v. De Cook)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-01-1933
KELLY, J.
Defendant insists that there is no substantial evidence in the record tending to show that
*577
defendant was negligent, and that defendant’s motion for a directed verdict for defendant should have been sustained.
Plaintiff was sixteen years of age at the time of the accident. He testified that at that time he was riding a bicycle upon the right side of the pavement about two feet from the edge thereof and that he was not riding “zigzag.” That without warning he was rendered unconscious. It is expressly admitted in the answer of defendant that a collision occurred between defendant’s automobile and plaintiff’s bicycle. Defendant was going in the same general direction as plaintiff and the accident happened while defendant was attempting to pass plaintiff. One of plaintiff’s witnesses testified that, at the place of the accident, there was a small pool of blood approximately four or five feet from the edge of the road on the right-hand lane of traffic going southerly. We think that the jury believed this testimony and were of the opinion that this blood came from plaintiff’s head and marked the place of the collision. Plaintiff’s body remained where he was struck upon the pavement for a short time and was then removed to an embankment at the side of the road and from there to a house nearby.
Defendant and his witnesses testified that the collision occurred on the left of the center of the pavement. One of defendant’s witnesses testified that the blood was within a foot of the center line of the pavement. This discloses a material contradiction, but does not justify this court in holding that there is no substantial testimony tending to show that defendant was negligent in “failing and neglecting to continue on the left-hand side of plaintiff until he was safely clear of
*578
the said bicycle,” and that defendant “turned his said automobile to the right before completely passing the plaintiff and directly into the left side of the plaintiff.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit