Supreme Court of Pennsylvania March 24, 1933, Appeal, 29 (Kirk v. McKnight)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-03-1933

Opinion by

Mr. Justice Schaffer,

This was an action for personal injuries sustained by plaintiff when struck by defendant’s truck. The jury returned a verdict in plaintiff’s favor. Defendant moved for judgment non obstante veredicto, which was granted. Plaintiff appeals.

*485

The record is most unsatisfactory to review. We are not certain in parts of it whether we are dealing with facts or surmises. This is caused by the mistiness of the recollections of witnesses due to the long interval between the time of the accident which brought about the litigation and the trial. The accident took place on January 29, 1924. Suit was not commenced until January 28, 1926, just before the statute had run. The trial was on May 21, 1931, more than seven years between accident and trial. We do not have the benefit of a brief from appellee and no oral argument was presented in his behalf.

Although the indications are that several persons were present at the scene of the accident, only four witnesses were called, the plaintiff, the driver of the truck which struck her, the person who conveyed her to the hospital and who apparently knew nothing about the occurrence except that he saw plaintiff lying in the street between the two car tracks, and a doctor. The absence of other witnesses is doubtless due to the lapse of time.

Plaintiff alighted from a westbound street car on the north side of Fifth Avenue in Pittsburgh. It was about dusk and snowing. The car had stopped at its usual stopping place to let passengers off at Brady Street, which intersects Fifth Avenue. A number of passengers alighted. Plaintiff was the last one off the car.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.